DOJ asks to end Alaska Senate certification lawsuit after Peltola wins

Must read

The Justice Department asked a federal appeals court on November 19 to end its Alaska Senate election lawsuit after Democrat Mary Peltola defeated Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan. The department wants the earlier ruling against it erased and the case dismissed as moot, ending its effort through this suit to delay certification over alleged voter confusion.

What happened

In its 19-page filing to the Ninth Circuit, the department said ballots had been mixed together without information identifying the voters who cast them. It acknowledged that the investigation it proposed could no longer determine whether people who selected Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. had intended to support Sen. Dan S. Sullivan.

The requested outcome has three steps: declare the case moot, vacate the district court’s dismissal order, and return the case for dismissal on that different ground. The government opposed simply affirming its earlier defeat. It also argued that sanctions were unwarranted.

U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason had dismissed the amended complaint on November 1 because the government failed to show that a court order could remedy its alleged injury. She dismissed it without prejudice and denied permission to amend again. The department appealed that day. The dismissal rested on standing, the requirement that a plaintiff show a court can address its injury. Gleason did not decide whether the government’s underlying statutory claims would succeed on their merits.

Gleason’s ruling said previously cast ballots could not be separated or traced to individual voters. It also found that the government had provided no workable plan for investigating voter intent while protecting ballot secrecy. Merely preserving the ballots would not resolve that problem; Alaska law already required their retention for 22 months.

Peltola won more than half the vote, so no ranked-choice redistribution was necessary, NBC reported. The Alaska Supreme Court had already allowed the second Sullivan to remain on the ballot.

How outlets covered it

NBC News led with the administration asking to abandon its civil suit and emphasized the unusual effort to block certification unless the incumbent Republican won. Its report placed the filing alongside Trump’s involvement and an earlier California ballot lawsuit. It also explained Peltola’s outright majority and included her denial of wrongdoing concerning the second Sullivan’s candidacy.

Washington Examiner framed its headline around dropping the certification challenge after Peltola won. Its opening paragraphs explained the two candidates’ similar names and identified the challenger as a retired Petersburg teacher. They also noted that the ballot identified the Republican senator as the incumbent. That opening emphasized the ballot’s distinctions alongside the government’s concern about confusion.

Associated Press emphasized the attempted certification block and objections from Alaska’s Republican-led government. Its opening also noted that the state Supreme Court had approved the second Sullivan’s candidacy. AP foregrounded resistance to the federal intervention rather than leading with the candidates’ ballot descriptions.

The reports agreed on the department’s retreat. NBC and AP gave more prominence to the attempted intervention in state election administration; the Examiner’s opening devoted more attention to why two Sullivan names appeared on the ballot and how they were distinguished.

What’s disputed

The legal disagreement over the earlier ruling remains. DOJ still argues that the district court could have ordered effective ballot-preservation measures before Election Day. Gleason concluded that its proposed remedy was unworkable and raised fundamental ballot-secrecy problems.

The November 19 filing asks the appeals court to resolve the case on mootness rather than endorse Gleason’s reasoning. It is a government request, not an appellate order granting that outcome. Whether the lower court’s ruling will be vacated remains for the Ninth Circuit to decide.

Opinion: The Civic Bearing’s Take

This section is opinion and reflects The Civic Bearing’s conservative perspective.

Conservatives should want election rules enforced consistently, including when their preferred candidate loses. A credible complaint needs a lawful, workable remedy. Ballot secrecy deserves protection even when a campaign’s conduct raises questions; public confidence cannot rest on asking voters to reconstruct their choices for investigators.

The department’s concession that no effective relief remains is a sensible reason to end this litigation. Its separate request to erase the earlier ruling deserves judicial scrutiny on its own legal grounds. Protecting election integrity and respecting the limits of federal power should reinforce one another. Neither principle should depend on which party benefits from the count.

How this article was produced

This article was generated using AI from the sources linked below. It does not include firsthand reporting or interviews. Our editors monitor published articles and correct errors promptly. Claims attributed to outside sources have not been independently verified by this publication.

Found an error? Email corrections@thecivicbearing.com.

Sources

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article